NEW Bay Area 25 Football Rankings

Defensive players from No. 19 and unbeaten McClymonds of Oakland are about to make a stop in game earlier this season against Oakland. Photo: Everett Bass.

Defensive players from No. 19 and unbeaten McClymonds of Oakland are about to make a stop in game earlier this season against Oakland. Photo: Everett Bass.

Here we go again in the wild-and-wacky WCAL as Archbishop Mitty jumbles the race and this week’s rankings with an upset of front-runner Serra. In other moves, Milpitas is now a clear-cut No. 2 while Palma of Salinas gets a jump along with Pittsburg and California of San Ramon.

To see the expanded version of the Cal-Hi Sports State 25 and for the full list of teams in the Cal-Hi Sports CIF State Bowl Game Rankings, you need to be a Gold Club member. This is a great time to sign up. To do that, CLICK HERE.

Please check out and bookmark our new Cal-Hi Sports Insider Blog: For simple updates and insights, check out our twitter page @CalHiSports and for other updates please visit our Facebook page.

The last time we were graced by working with Sister Frances was when she operated the scoreboard during a WCAL boys home basketball game at Sacred Heart Cathedral two seasons ago. Prior to that, it was in the press box at Kezar Stadium for an Irish home football game at their currently under repair (new track) home away from home. She also was around long before working the scoreboard for the Irish girls basketball team we witnessed that was No. 1 in the nation several years ago.

This past Friday afternoon at the temporary football home of the Irish at Westmoor of Daly City, Sister Frances was in her usual position at the controls of the scoreboard in the Westmoor press box.

If there’s one thing we’ve learned in watching Sister Frances for a couple of decades at the various Irish scoreboard helms is that if you give Sister her space and the respect she deserves, and occasionally engage her in some conversation, working beside the little lady can be quite entertaining.

Besides guiding the student-announcer through the opening prayer, she never hesitated to correct the young man any number of times on the finer points of announcing. She also has opinions, and not surprisingly almost always favoring the Irish.

St. Francis head coach Greg Calcagno talks to the players after win last Friday in Daly City. Photo: Harold Abend.

St. Francis head coach Greg Calcagno talks to the players after win last Friday in Daly City. Photo: Harold Abend.

“That was not a first down,” she groaned on a close placement by the officials.

“Oh gosh, can you please tackle Irish,” she yelled out the window as St. Francis running back Lutoviko Ahoia broke loose en route to a school record 325 yards rushing with three touchdowns on 30 carries to lead the Lancers to an exciting 27-21 victory.

After it became apparent the Irish would not pull out a victory when they failed to recover an onside kick after recording the game’s final score, Sister Frances had some words for yours truly.

“Well, you didn’t turn around our luck. We still haven’t won since you did that story on Logan.”

Sister is correct. After SHC broke out 3-0 this season, we penned a story on Irish quarterback Logan White and his being the son of San Francisco Fire Chief Joanne Hayes-White. Since then, the team has lost all five of its West Catholic Athletic League games. For his part, White had a great game after completing 22 of 29 passes for 287 yards and two touchdowns. The Irish defense just couldn’t stop the run.

The Cal-Hi Sports caravan wasn’t at the Serra vs. Archbishop Mitty game but the fact we were on the Peninsula must have carried the mojo south from Daly City to Foothill College where Serra was dropped from the ranks of WCAL unbeatens after falling 27-14 to Mitty.

The loss creates a three-way tie atop the wild-and-wacky WCAL between Bellarmine, Serra and Valley Christian. Mitty and St. Francis are next at 3-2 and frankly who would have thought it would be any different.

Serra has the road loss to Mitty but a road win over Valley Christian and a date with Bellarmine at home in two weeks after a match-up this week with Sacred Heart Cathedral at Terra Nova in Pacifica.

Valley Christian has the home loss to Serra but came back at home the next week to pin a 42-17 loss on Bellarmine, plus the Warriors have a win over the St. Francis team that has a win over Mitty. The Warriors face Mitty this week.

Bellarmine has the loss to Valley Christian but has a win over Mitty. Before finishing WCAL play with Serra, the Bells also meet a St. Francis team that has the win over Mitty but losses to Serra and Valley Christian.

After looking over the who-beat-whos this season trying to figure out who goes to the top of the WCAL pecking order looks like it should require the use of a Ouija board, but we’ll take a stab without one.

The one thing the WCAL shake-up does do is elevate Milpitas and Los Gatos of the De Anza League and actually the CCS in general as eight of the top 11 teams in the Bay Area this week are from the CCS…but that’s temporary since some of those teams are playing each other.

CLICK HERE for all the info on how to win free tickets to Levi's Stadium to see the 49ers.

CLICK HERE for all the info on how to win free tickets to Levi’s Stadium to see the 49ers.

Here are the ninth rankings of the 2014 season (after games of Saturday, Oct. 31; previous ranking in parentheses):

1. (1) De La Salle (Concord) 9-0
Andrew Hernandez rushed for 133 yards and two touchdowns and Javari Anderson rushed for a TD and returned an interception for a second score in a 56-0 win over a Pleasanton Amador Valley team that was only able to muster 123 total yards. Next up is a California of San Ramon team fresh off a victory over San Ramon Valley.

2. (3) Milpitas 8-0
The Trojans are in a place they’ve never been before, and that’s at No. 2 in Bay Area after a thrilling 27-21 victory over Los Gatos. Milpitas should be the top seed in the CCS Open Division playoffs and the pundits and prognosticators are beginning to wonder if Milpitas will be the team to eventually challenge Folsom in the CIF NorCal Division I bowl game. For more on the game, CLICK HERE.

Foothill's Kyle Kearns is one of the best QBs in the Bay Area. Photo: Mark Tennis.

Foothill’s Kyle Kearns is one of the best QBs in the Bay Area. Photo: Mark Tennis.

3. (4) Foothill (Pleasanton) 8-1
It was no cakewalk but Foothill clinched its first EBAL title since 2006 with a 28-21 victory over Granada. Coach Matt Sweeney’s team also gets to rise one spot in these rankings due to Serra’s loss to Mitty.

4. (2) Serra (San Mateo) 5-3
The deciding factor in keeping the Padres as the highest ranked team from the WCAL is the road win over a Valley Christian team that has a win over a Bellarmine team that has a win over Mitty. Plus, Serra meets Bellarmine in two weeks.

5. (5) Valley Christian (San Jose) 6-2
It looked for sure like the Warriors were going down to defeat to St. Ignatius after giving up a touchdown and two-point conversion to trail 15-14 with 37.9 seconds left. What would have made things even wilder and wackier in the WCAL didn’t happen, however, as quarterback Michael Machado did his best Joe Montana impression and led VC 70-yards in four plays in the final moments for Nathan Parkin’s 22-yard field goal on the final play of the game to pull out a 17-15 victory. The matchup with Mitty this week should be the WCAL game to watch.

6. (6) Clayton Valley (Concord) 8-0
There was strong consideration to moving Clayton Valley ahead of Serra and Valley Christian but their resume just doesn’t warrant it at this time and they are already ahead of one WCAL co-leader (Bellarmine). The Ugly Eagles rolled Concord Ygnacio Valley 69-13 in this weekend’s game.

7. (7) Bellarmine (San Jose) 7-1
The Bells posted a 28-15 win over visiting Riordan of San Francisco that wasn’t anywhere close as the score indicates. The hosts had a 28-0 lead midway through the fourth quarter before the reserves yielded two scores. Prior to meeting Serra in two weeks, the Bells play St. Francis at San Jose City College in a matchup that has huge WCAL implications.

8. (11) Palma (Salinas) 8-0
The time has come to give the Chieftains credit for their resume and move them up even though they were tied 7-7 with host Monterey late in the third quarter, and Monterey even had a good chance to take the lead before Palma put it away with two fourth quarter TDs in a 21-7 victory. The factor for the move is being unbeaten including a win over a St. Francis team that has a win over Mitty.

9. (8) Los Gatos 6-2
The Cats jumped out to a 14-0 lead against unbeaten Milpitas, but the size and depth of the Trojans was too much in a 27-21 loss. Still, with the only other loss to St. Mary’s of Stockton plus another huge win over Mitty, Los Gatos only drops one spot in the rankings. For game recap, CLICK HERE.

10. (12) St. Francis (Mountain View) 5-3
The offense that had been lacking in league losses to Serra and Valley Christian the past two weeks came alive when the Lancers used a powerful running game to rack up 409 yards on the ground in the victory over Sacred Heart Cathedral. The only other loss is to Palma and there’s a big game this week against Bellarmine.

11. (10) Campolindo (Moraga) 9-0
As expected Campo took out arch rival Miramonte (Orinda) in a 49-12 victory against a team that is only a shadow of the defending NCS D2 champions of last season. The Cougars drop below some CCS teams that have big recent and prior wins but that should change if Campo continues winning and captures the NCS D3 title and teams above them beat each other from here out.

Brett Foley was a standout for Archbishop Mitty in its upset of San Mateo Serra. Photo: Student Sports.

Brett Foley was a standout for Archbishop Mitty of San Jose in its upset of San Mateo Serra. Photo: Student Sports.

12. (13) Archbishop Mitty (San Jose) 5-3
The Monarchs’ 27-14 win over Serra has to count for something so despite losses to Los Gatos, St. Francis and Bellarmine, the Monarchs get to move up and stay behind Saint Francis. The move up will be even bigger next week if they can take down Valley Christian this week.

13. (9) James Logan (Union City) 7-2
The Colts continue to roll with a 42-6 victory over Washington of Fremont. They wouldn’t normally drop four spots after a result like that, but are making room for unbeaten Palma plus St. Francis and Mitty, which is all related to Mitty’s win over Serra.

14. (15) Pittsburg 7-2
With a 24-13 victory over Freedom to clinch the BVAL title combined with California knocking off San Ramon Valley, the Pirates get to climb a bit in this week’s rankings. Neighboring Antioch is on tap to close out league play.

15. (17) California (San Ramon) 7-2
The who beat who in the East Bay Athletic League and Bay Valley Athletic League power leagues of the NCS isn’t as wild as in the WCAL and California’s win over San Ramon Valley puts the Grizzlies firmly in second-place in the EBAL.

16. (14) San Ramon Valley (Danville) 5-4
The past win over Pittsburg on the road keeps the Wolves in the rankings even with four losses. Next up is host Danville Monte Vista to close out league play.

17. (16) St. Ignatius (San Francisco) 4-4
The best .500 team in the Bay Area has been involved in some heart-breaking, heart-stoppers. The Wildcats rallied to beat Marin Catholic, held off Terra Nova, beat Stockton St. Mary’s in double overtime, and then lost three close games to Bellarmine, Serra and Mitty. They then handled arch-rival Sacred Heart Cathedral. This past week it looked like a late fourth quarter touchdown and 2-point conversion was going to get them an upset against Valley Christian, but this time the hammer fell on the Wildcats as the Warriors rallied in the final 37.9 seconds to stun SI in a 17-15 loss.

18. (19) Concord 7-1*
*Win by forfeit not included. As expected, the Minutemen overran Walnut Creek Northgate 62-27 in a scoreboard lighter-upper. Next up is Ygnacio Valley.

19. (20) McClymonds (Oakland) 9-0
In a 40-8 victory, Mack made fast work of a Skyline team many thought was the second-best OAL team. The win over Salesian is looking real good but the cloud of whether the Warriors have forfeits in their future is the big question as we get close to the playoffs.

20. (21) Sacred Heart Prep (Atherton) 8-0
With or without Washington-bound Ben Burr-Kirven, the Gators haven’t blown away anyone that was decent but they’re still perfect after a 31-21 win over Atherton Menlo-Atherton.

21. (18) Freedom (Oakley) 6-3
Despite a 24-13 loss to Pittsburg, their resume in this group including the fact they’re still in second place in the Bay Valley Athletic League, keeps them in the rankings but lower. Brentwood Liberty on the road is next up.

22. (22) Salesian (Richmond) 7-2
The Pride go to 5-0 in the Tri-County–Rock League with a 21-10 win over visiting El Cerrito. If Salesian goes on to win the NCS D5 title, it could be in a position to get a NorCal D4 Bowl bid depending on the McClymonds forfeit situation and what happens in the CIF Sac-Joaquin Section.

23. (23) St. Mary’s (Berkeley) 8-1
The Panthers had a bye and will face host Pinole Valley of Pinole this week.

24. (25) Wilcox (Santa Clara) 6-2
The No. 3 team from the De Anza League rebounded from being shut out by Milpitas by shutting out Cupertino Monta Vista 41-0.

25. (24) San Leandro 5-4
The Pirates continue toward the 6-4 record to enter the playoffs we predicted several weeks ago after a 57-14 shellacking of Castro Valley. It was San Leandro’s biggest offensive output of the season.

Dropped Out:

Teams On the Bubble
(In alphabetical order)

Acalanes (Lafayette) 7-2
Alhambra (Martinez) 7-2
Amador Valley (Pleasanton) 5-4
Analy (Sebastopol) 8-1
Antioch 6-3
Aptos 7-1
Aragon (San Mateo) 8-0
Burlingame 8-0
Cardinal Newman (Santa Rosa) 6-3
Carmel 6-2
Deer Valley (Antioch) 4-5
El Cerrito 4-5
Justin-Siena (Napa) 6-3
Kennedy (Fremont) 9-0
Las Lomas (Walnut Creek) 7-2
Liberty (Brentwood) 7-2
Marin Catholic (Kentfield) 6-3
Monte Vista (Danville) 3-6
Monterey 7-2
Novato 6-3
Piedmont 9-0
Pioneer (San Jose) 7-1
Rancho Cotate (Rohnert Park) 6-3
Sacred Heart Cathedral (San Francisco) 3-5
Salinas 5-4
San Benito (Hollister) 4-4
Terra Nova (Pacifica) 3-5
Windsor 7-2

Harold Abend is the associate editor of and the vice president of the California Prep Sportswriters Association. He can be reached at Don’t forget to follow him on Twitter: @HaroldAbend

Enjoy this article?

Find out how you can get access to more exclusive content, one-of-a-kind California high school sports content!

Learn More


  1. monte300
    Posted November 3, 2014 at 9:52 am | Permalink

    Not sure why SRV is still ranked in the top 25? That win over Pittsburg seems like so long ago and they got a questionable second try at tying that game up sending it to overtime. SRV just hasn’t been playing well lately.

    • phishan
      Posted November 3, 2014 at 2:23 pm | Permalink

      Seems SRV at 5-4 has been getting more than the benefit of the doubt all year. Their ranking is not surprising anymore to me but still puzzling. Cal at 7-2 is only one notch higher. It could be worse look at #17, What????a 500 football team ranked in the top 20 with one league win? Maybe you guys should change your name to the WCALhisports!

      • Mark Tennis
        Posted November 3, 2014 at 4:03 pm | Permalink

        SI also has a win over 8-1 St. Mary’s of Stockton plus Marin Catholic. Guess we should put Piedmont, Aragon, Acalanes or Kennedy-Fremont in there instead of them?

        • Phishan
          Posted November 4, 2014 at 2:06 pm | Permalink

          I do agree with you Mark that some losses to tough teams should not end a good program’s season. You can’t justify four losses and one league win in my opinion. My point is that there is a lot of good football in Bay Area and yes another team is more deserving than SI’s #17 ranking. I find your rankings to be favorable to WCAL teams. I really was questioning SRV’s and Cal’s rankings but also noticing what you choose to respond to is insightful. Fun to debate anyway.

        • Jim Edens
          Posted November 5, 2014 at 3:03 pm | Permalink

          Yes… Kennedy – Fremont should be at least as high as Salesian or St. Mary’s. St. Mary’s beat Moreau Catholic 39-6 and beat Hercules 42-0. Kennedy beat Moreau Catholic 44-14 and beat Hercules 57-0. Pretty comparable I’d say. Salesian beat Hercules 35-7, again nothing more impressive than Kennedy. The MVAL never gets respect in the polls though, and I understand that this year, most of the teams aren’t particularly good, but Kennedy has done what they should do to bad teams… they’ve blown them out.

  2. Grey Crane
    Posted November 3, 2014 at 11:28 am | Permalink

    No 4-loss team should be in the top 25, period. Quality losses are still losses. There are too many other teams on this list’s “bubble” that are deserving. But then again, most people I talk to discount this list entirely. It’s good for a laugh, and that’s about it.

    • monte300
      Posted November 3, 2014 at 1:24 pm | Permalink

      The teams on the bubble that probably deserve a spot on the top 25 list IMO are Liberty, Las Lomas and Acalanes.

      • phishan
        Posted November 3, 2014 at 2:05 pm | Permalink

        Monte Vista at 3-6 is on the bubble?

        • monte300
          Posted November 3, 2014 at 2:44 pm | Permalink

          At least Monte Vista has been playing better as of late.

      • Grey Crane
        Posted November 3, 2014 at 3:05 pm | Permalink

        As I’ve mentioned here before, Liberty beat San Leandro AND has a better record! But somehow they are on the “bubble” and San Leandro is ranked?
        Enough said.

  3. joebl
    Posted November 3, 2014 at 12:09 pm | Permalink

    Your comment, “Milpitas seems headed to be the top seed in the CCS Open Division playoffs ” is incorrect. Milpitas is headed to being the #3 seed in the CCS Open Division playoffs behind both Palma and Sacred Heart Prep.

    • monte300
      Posted November 3, 2014 at 2:50 pm | Permalink

      I would think overall strength of schedule would rank Milpitas above Palma and SHP.

    • Mark Tennis
      Posted November 3, 2014 at 3:48 pm | Permalink

      Thanks, I will just change that to “should be the top seed in the CCS Open Division playoffs.”

  4. coach
    Posted November 3, 2014 at 12:12 pm | Permalink

    simply absurd a .500 team is ranked that high. just like last year – st igantius thought they would roll d3 ccs and got beat by aptos. aptos only loss to granite bay which is playing very well.

    • Mark Tennis
      Posted November 3, 2014 at 3:49 pm | Permalink

      We just aren’t going to drop out an SI team that got beat on a last-second score by a very good team. I agree that Aptos should be higher and we’ll make every attempt to fix that next week.

      • Grey Crane
        Posted November 4, 2014 at 7:48 am | Permalink

        So you have to admit, then that you are biased with regards to SI and other pet schools. When they lose in the last seconds to an”good” team, it doesn’t count. When Antioch loses in the last seconds to a very good Wood team, it does count. The rankings are totally arbitrary based on you baseless assumptions. Thanks for admitting it finally.

        • Mark Tennis
          Posted November 4, 2014 at 8:49 am | Permalink

          How is that being biased? Sometimes, a team can and should move up if it were to play a “good” team and lose in a close game. It’s a “baseless assumption” that St. Mary’s of Stockton is a good team, which SI did beat? That team is 8-1 and also beat Los Gatos.

          • Grey Crane
            Posted November 4, 2014 at 8:55 am | Permalink

            In the immortal words of Denny Green, “you are what your record says you are.” One or two close losses, OK. But 4-4 means you are a bubble team at best. But keep defending the point. It only lessens the validity of your rankings.

          • monte300
            Posted November 4, 2014 at 12:04 pm | Permalink

            Actually, Green said “they are who we thought they were”…………..point taken…..

          • Phishan
            Posted November 4, 2014 at 2:20 pm | Permalink

            The tuna said you are what your record says you are. Denny Green did say “they are who we thought they were” about the Chicago Bears, unbeaten at the time. Mark I think you guys are alone in your steadfastness that SI is deserving of a top 20 ranking in all Bay Area with a .500 record. With playoffs around the corner I think the only way you can prove your point is for SI to go deep and surprise some people.

          • Grey Crane
            Posted November 4, 2014 at 3:14 pm | Permalink

            My bad. It WAS the Tuna. Thanks for the correction.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *


    Latest News

    Insider Blog