Should CIF Ban Games vs. IMG?

If anybody has any more doubt that the IMG Academy football program of Bradenton, Florida is playing on a different level and with different rules about getting players to go there than just about any “school” in the nation, all the news this week about the University of Michigan practicing there basically to help its recruitment of IMG players should be the final nail in the coffin.

IMG has obviously adopted the philosophy of super private school academy-style basketball programs like Findlay Prep of Henderson, Nev., and Montverde Academy (also of Florida). The University of Tennessee has reportedly made offers to 20 IMG players so far who will be on this fall’s team and this summer’s The Opening by Nike in Beaverton, Ore., will be another IMG promotional bonanza with many IMG players getting salivated upon by the recruiting media.
The Buzz 150
The IMG team does not play in the Florida high school state championships but seeks out teams from around the country in an attempt to get a high national ranking. Last year’s team went 9-0 and was in the top 10 of several polls but did have a couple of close games against two teams from New Jersey – 59-47 vs. Bergen Catholic and 28-20 vs. Paramus Catholic.

Next season’s team, which should be insanely talented, is playing Corona Centennial at the Honor Bowl on Labor Day weekend in Mission Viejo. Maybe the Huskies can give the IMG team a contest, and hopefully they do but based on IMG’s obvious ability to get players literally from anywhere in the nation it may be a tall task. It also will hopefully be the last time a California team plays IMG in football.

Per CIF rules, California boys basketball teams aren’t allowed to play some of these prep schools (Findlay Prep) even though they have some kind of membership in a state association. IMG in football should be viewed the same way.

If players like Brian Hightower of Calabasas and others from California truly believe moving across the country to go to IMG is going to greatly benefit them, we wish them nothing but the best and completely understand. Why any regular public/private school state association allow these super private prep school powerhouses to schedule games against their members is what doesn’t make sense.

We’ll wait to see what happens against Corona Centennial, but the first time an academy-style football team with 20 or 30 Division I recruits and five or six All-Americans (some who came to that school from all over the country) obliterates a California team, then anybody else scheduling that school should have their heads examined.

At least private schools like De La Salle and St. John Bosco don’t often collect players from hundreds of miles away. And we know from recent history (Long Beach Poly, Centennial, etc.) that it’s very possible for a public school to be more than competitive. IMG is taking it to an entirely different level. Pat them on the back perhaps the first time an IMG team runs the table and is No. 1 in the nation. After that, make them go play small colleges.


Enjoy this article?

Find out how you can get access to more exclusive content, one-of-a-kind California high school sports content!

Learn More

3 Comments

  1. Tiny Tim Preps
    Posted March 5, 2016 at 8:08 am | Permalink

    Mark

    Great article!
    I wish everyone would refer to these programs as to what they are: OUTLAW PROGRAMS since they’re outside the rules of any state high school athletic organization.
    2 things would cripple these programs quite badly. One would be for all the sports media to stop ranking them with other high schools. (I think Cal Hi Sports does not rank them. I wish your “pals” up in Auburn would do the same. However, I’ve never seen the one Northern California “outlaw” ranked in Joe Davidson’s weekly NorCal Top 25 for basketball.)
    Two. I doubt if many of these “schools” top athletes are paying for their own tuition and B&R. These institutions have to be getting corporate money from somewhere. National boycotts of these outfits’ products would shut these programs down very quickly.

    TinyTim

    • Mark Tennis
      Posted March 5, 2016 at 8:57 am | Permalink

      They’re mostly getting shoe money. MaxPreps does rank the super private academies in separate categories. We were putting them in the FAB 50s because some of them are associate members of state associations (that’s how they get eligible for national rankings). The state associations and NFHS are the ones that can take a stand and stop accepting them. I would have no problem if for example there were eight of these academies around the nation for example and they were simply competing against each other. The “normal” high schools wouldn’t mind that at all, either.

  2. bright seed
    Posted August 27, 2017 at 10:01 am | Permalink

    IMG has great talent no doubt. For the record, IMG beat Centinnel 50-49. This IMG defense that should be”playing college teams” won by a point in overtime and gave up 49 points to a team that is not the best team in their division. IMG did not finish atop the 2016-17 national rankings nor do they dominate good teams. They would not beat Bishop Gorman, St. John Bosco, St. Thomas Aquinas, Mater Dei, De Matha and a whole lot of others would give them a run for their money or beat them. I don’t care how many recruits they get its near impossible to corner the market at the HS level.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*

    Latest News

    Insider Blog

    Cal-Hi Sports on Twitter

    Cal-Hi Sports on Facebook