Mr. Football State Player of the Year Tracker

Concord High’s Olito Thompson already has nearly 1,000 yards rushing, but that’s still not even one-third of what he racked up last season as a junior.

First look at top candidates for 2012 season honor still shows the 2011 Junior of the Year in the lead. Check Thursday on this page for the latest installment of State Stat Stars.

Note: The list of honorees who have been Mr. Football State Player of the Year by Cal-Hi Sports extends back to 1890 and includes Toby Gerhart of Norco (2005), D.J. Williams of Concord De La Salle (1999), John Elway of Granada Hills (1978), Marcus Allen of San Diego Lincoln (1977), Dick Bass of Vallejo (1954) and Morley Drury of Long Beach Poly (1923). Last year’s winner was receiver Deontay Greenberry from Washington of Easton. This year’s winner will be named in early January and will include all performances through the CIF state bowl championship games. Writeups below by Mark Tennis, Ronnie Flores and Paul Muyskens.


Su’a Cravens (Vista Murrieta, Murrieta)
The 6-1, 210-pound senior was the 2011 State Junior of the Year and is on track for another very strong and possibly sensational season. Cravens, who also was the 2011 L.A. Times Player of the Year (including seniors), has led the Broncos to a 5-0 start to their season. He has scored four times on pass receptions, twice on rushes and on defense he is averaging nine tackles per game with a high of 13. Cravens also has two sacks, scored on a 86-yard interception return and has blocked a punt. He has committed to USC.

Note: Only one Cal-Hi Sports State Junior of the Year in the past two decades has come back to be Mr. Football as a senior and that would be current Denver Broncos linebacker D.J. Williams from Concord De La Salle, who was the junior winner for the 1998 season and was Mr. Football for 1999.


Jared Goff (Marin Catholic, Kentfield) QB
Showing why he will be headed to Cal next season, Goff recently went a perfect 8 for 8 for 155 yards and four touchdowns in a 51-12 win over Redwood of Larkspur. Last season, he passed for 3,210 yards and 45 touchdowns while leading the Wildcats to the CIF North Coast Section Division III championship game. During the offseason, he was one of two quarterbacks from Northern California to be selected to compete in the Elite 11 quarterback competition. Out of the 24 quarterbacks in attendance, Goff finished ranked No. 6. Goff’s team also is currently the top-ranked team in our Division II North Bowl Game rankings with a record of 5-1.

Michael Hutchings (De La Salle, Concord) LB
Much like Michael Barton was last year, Hutchings is the most visible and senior leader of a dominant Spartans’ defense. Barton, now at Cal, was eventually a Mr. Football finalist. Hutchings (6-3, 210) is committed to USC and might have the speed to be converted to strong safety. He also gets onto the field on offense as a tight end and extra running back on the goal line. Hutchings’ possibilities to be Mr. Football depend on De La Salle’s success as a team and how many impressive outings the defensive unit turns in. It also could depend on how many touchdowns running back Tiapepe Vitale scores on offense. Vitale, in the end, could be the team’s top honors candidate if he has 40 touchdowns or more.

Eddie Vanderdoes (Placer, Auburn) DL-FB
Whether the Hillmen end up in a CIF NorCal Division II or Division III bowl game, it’s going to be the force of Vanderdoes, all 6-4, 305 pounds of him, that mostly paves the way. Vanderdoes, who has committed to USC and is one of the top-ranked defensive line prospects in the nation, has helped Placer to a 5-0 start. He is averaging five tackles per game, routinely draws double and triple teams, and has 4.5 sacks and one safety. Vanderdoes also can be devastating as blocking fullback on offense.

Troy Williams (Narbonne, Harbor City) QB
The 6-foot-0 175-pound signal-caller is the L.A. City Section’s most dynamic dual-threat QB since Taft’s Josh Portis in 2004 or even San Pedro’s Melvin Yarbrough in 1996. Not since Yarbrough has there been a highly regarded dual-threat QB with the opportunity to lead a L.A. City Section team to an unbeaten season and top five state rating. So far, the Washington-bound Williams has completed 63 of 93 pass attempts for 882 yards with seven touchdowns against three interceptions. He also has five rushing touchdowns so far against top-notch competition. Williams plays a lot like Washington’s current QB, St. John Bosco product Keith Price, when he attended St. John Bosco with the main difference being Williams has a lot more talent around him. That will play to his advantage as Narbonne has a legitimate chance to become the L.A. City Section’s first program to win a CIF state title in the modern era.


Johnny Stanton (Santa Margarita, Rancho SM) QB-RB
The 6-foot-2, 220-pound Stanton was the heart and soul of the defending CIF Div. I state champions. We say was because two weeks ago after he led the Eagles to a thrilling non-league victory over St. Bonaventure of Ventura, it was announced the following weekend that Stanton would miss the remainder of this season with an ACL injury. The Nebraska-bound Stanton is still listed on the tracker since he has not yet technically missed a game. Even without playing any more games, Stanton is the Eagles’ all-time total offense leader with 5,558 yards and 4th on the school’s career passing yardage list with 3,576 yards. If Stanton hadn’t gotten hurt, it’s safe to say he’d be the No. 2 player on the tracker after Vista Murrieta’s Su’a Cravens.


Jake Browning (Folsom) QB
Not even originally projected to be the Bulldogs’ starting quarterback, this sophomore got national attention in his very first start as he passed for 689 yards and 10 touchdowns in a 68-28 win over Woodcreek of Roseville. Browning looks to be the next Folsom quarterback set to put up big yearly and career numbers. His career numbers have a chance to pass 2010 Mr. Football Dano Graves and Tanner Trosin and the system the Bulldogs run puts points up in a hurry. Entering this week’s game with unbeaten Oak Ridge of El Dorado Hills in a matchup of two 5-0 teams, Browning has passed for 2,010 yards and 19 touchdowns. In addition to Graves being the Mr. Football winner two years ago, Trosin was a finalist last season.

Conner Manning (El Toro, Lake Forest) QB
After passing for 4,219 yards and 41 touchdowns in his junior year, this talented signal caller is on pace to throw for even more yards this season. After six games (all El Toro wins), Manning had thrown for 2.572 yards and 27 touchdowns to help the Chargers rank No. 22 in our latest state rankings. Manning’s best game of the season was one for the record books as he broke the Orange County record for passing yards in a game when he went 45 of 59 for 613 yards and seven touchdowns in a 77-46 win over Valhalla of El Cajon. The seven touchdown passes in a game wasn’t a record but it was his career high. The Utah-bound Manning has thrown for at least 313 yards and three touchdowns in every game this season.

Olito Thompson (Concord) RB
Although Thompson is on pace for 2,000 yards rushing for the regular season, he is still known for his playoff rampage from last year. He finished with 3,488 yards and 34 touchdowns. It was an all-time best for Northern California for yardage in a season and ranked No. 4 in the state. Thompson had 11 carries for 251 yards and three touchdowns in his first outing this year and was sitting at 894 yards and 12 TDs entering this week’s action. Thompson has committed to Washington State.

Others who could make a charge, especially if their teams win major section or state championships or if they continue to put up record-breaking totals:

Levon Coleman (Lompoc) RB
Devon Dunn (Alemany, Mission Hills) QB-RB
Ian Feihler (Mission Viejo) QB
Robert Frazier (Elk Grove) RB
Zachary Green (St. Bonaventure, Ventura) RB
Joe Mathis (Upland) DE-TE
James Toland (Shadow Hills, Indio) RB
Tiapepe Vitale (De La Salle, Concord) RB
Drew Wolitarsky (Canyon, Canyon Country) WR

Comments or questions? Email

Enjoy this article?

Find out how you can get access to more exclusive content, one-of-a-kind California high school sports content!

Learn More


  1. Brent
    Posted October 5, 2012 at 1:55 pm | Permalink

    you should take a look at Ondre Rudolph of Dublin, more yards, more TD’s than Thompson in the East Bay

  2. Chaminade
    Posted October 8, 2012 at 7:35 am | Permalink

    Terrell newby of Chaminade RB has 1100 yards and 12 TD’s against better competition(Serra, Oaks Christian, Notre dame, Valencia, Venice, Pulaski) than any of the other RB’s listed. Plus he never coughs the ball up , he has only 1 fumble in over 750 carries in his carreer to go with 4500 yards and 65 rushing TD’s to date. Have you guys heard of Newby?

    • Posted October 8, 2012 at 9:01 am | Permalink

      Newby was on the all-state underclass team last season so yes we have heard of him.
      He’s not as highly regarded as the Lompoc RB but they are in the same division and if Chaminade wins it and Newby does better he’ll naturally get higher post-season honors.

  3. Chaminade
    Posted October 8, 2012 at 9:47 pm | Permalink

    Is he as highly regarded as Toland, Green, Frazier, Dunn?

    So the fact that Newby is durable beyond belief, never fumbles, has led his team to a top 15 ranking in the state, top 80 in the nation and plays against a high level of competition,doesn’t matter to Calhisports unless his team wins a championship? Thats a lame answer dude, If you didnt know, Coleman has been in civies for 2 weeks doing nothing on the field. Lompoc plays very weak competition and Newby has out gained Coleman almost 3 to 1 in yards and TD’s . Elk Grove and Shadow Hills play much weaker competition than Chaminade also.

    Stanton is out for the season and wont be back so you should take him off the list completely, whats the point of having him on the list?

    But this isn’t just about Coleman and Newby but every other back on your list, not mentioning Newby makes your list uncredible.

    • Posted October 8, 2012 at 10:39 pm | Permalink

      Yes, we know Coleman has been hurt. We also think we were justified leaving Stanton on the list for the first tracker to let people know where he would have been. Also, Elk Grove does not play “much weaker” competition than a CIF Southern Section Western Division team. Newby will definitely be on the second tracker if he keeps it up.

  4. Chaminade
    Posted October 9, 2012 at 12:28 am | Permalink

    You dont realize that Elk grove plays a weaker schedule than Chaminade?

    Are you serious?

    So far Elk Grove schedule has been MMMMUUUUCCCHHH weaker, and it doesnt get any better. Not to disrespect but any real HS football analyst ion the state of California knows that.’

    Compare the schedules.

    The best team by far that Elk Grove has played is Del Campo and they barely squeaked past them.

    Del Campo is at the level of the worst team Chaminade has played.

    Is this your first year in the business or what because you guys are looking like amateurs

    I think I get it now, there is obviously a serious bias on Calhisports toward favoring Northern Ca teams.

  5. Chaminade
    Posted October 9, 2012 at 12:34 am | Permalink

    Chaminades schedule strength on Calpreps is 45.7 Elk Grove is 17.1

    Even if you dont agree with Calpreps you have to know that they have a proven track record when handicapping HS football that nobody else can touch.

    Even if we allow for a monumental screw up by calpreps and give Elk Grove 20 points to their schedule strength average, they are still well below Chaminades schedule strength.

    Like I said its not even close. Facts are facts.

  6. Chaminade
    Posted October 9, 2012 at 12:36 am | Permalink

    Lompoc Schedule is twice as weak as Elk Groves by the way.

  7. Chaminade
    Posted October 9, 2012 at 12:39 am | Permalink

    Servite and Carson are the only 2 teams in the state with a better overall schedule than Chaminade 😉

  8. Posted October 9, 2012 at 8:25 am | Permalink

    Elk Grove’s schedule strength will come way up in the next few weeks. Chaminade’s will go down. We do rankings based on many other factors as well, such as previous track record and Elk Grove also was a 12-1 team from last season. We also watch the teams play, which last I checked a computer doesn’t. Elk Grove is No. 2 in Northern California by nearly everyone and we only have two NorCal teams in the top 10. Don’t see how not putting up Chaminade ahead of Elk Grove is evidence of a bias toward NorCal, but you are obviously a Chaminade fan so the bias on your part is plain to see. You are welcome to have more comments and get the last word, but on this topic we’ll move on.

  9. Chaminade
    Posted October 9, 2012 at 9:08 am | Permalink

    Im giving facts not bias and you have completely missed the point.
    Although Chaminade is better than Elk Grove in my opinion and most experts opinions, my aim was to compare the quality of teams that Newby and these other RB’s like the kid from Elk grove and Coleman have faced and will face.
    Newby has faced the better competition by far and you have failed miserably trying to defend your statement. The top 25 is another subject all together.

    What does elk groves record from last season have to do with their schedule strength this season.

    I didnt even know they were in your top 25 until you mentioned it, wow! #9 thats a stretch.

  10. Chaminade
    Posted October 20, 2012 at 5:44 pm | Permalink

    Like I said Newby 360 yards 8 td’s in 1 half.

    Frazier 83 yards 25 carries

    Above ALL else, You got to earn it against good competition in my mind, every year.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *


    Latest News

    Insider Blog